Skip to content

Drag0nista's Blog

Views from the aerie

  • My book: On Merit
  • Who is Drag0nista?
  • Published pieces
  • Drag0nista in the media
  • Contact
  • Need a freelance writer?
    • Writing samples
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Google +

Turnbull wants a more mature conversation, but will the media go along with it?

It is certainly commendable that Malcolm Turnbull is encouraging a kinder, gentler way of debating politics, but he shouldn’t ignore voters’ appetite for tabloid-confected conflict and drama.


Not long after Tony Abbott became prime minister, he learned it was impossible to manage an issue that’s captured the media’s attention if you’ve essentially vacated the field.

Abbott’s “courageous” attempt to slow the media cycle failed under the onslaught of media attention when the first “wedding gate” saga erupted just weeks after his Government’s election.

In response, Abbott adopted a new media strategy that was as frenetic as his predecessor Kevin Rudd’s, obsessed with winning the news cycle using an endless rotation of hi-vis vests and flag-infested podiums.

Now our latest PM has flagged yet another approach to communicating with the Australian community.

Malcolm Turnbull has promised advocacy instead of slogans (though Treasurer Scott Morrison may not yet have received that message), to listen and be open to new ideas, and to treat voters as adults by having a national conversation about the need for reform and what those changes will entail.

And as we saw over the past weekend, the new Turnbull way also includes a different response to tragic events that may involve home-grown extremism.

The Government had already flagged late last week that it intended to move away from the divisive language used by Abbott, which reportedly had led to Muslim groups feeling marginalised and distrustful of government. The PM put this into practice on the weekend, following the police shooting of a young gunman who had killed a police employee.

Noting that the “Australian Muslim community will be especially appalled and shocked by this,” Turnbull stressed, “We must not vilify or blame the entire Muslim community with the actions of what is, in truth, a very, very small percentage of violent extremist individuals.”

According to Foreign Minister Julie Bishop, the PM also extended this conciliatory approach to a phone hook-up held with Muslim community leaders to discuss taking a “holistic approach” to combating violent extremism.

Turnbull’s overhaul of the Government’s communication strategy isn’t limited to setting a new tone and pumping out fresh messages. It also involves dissuading the media from behaving in what the former PM called a “febrile” manner.

In an attempt to inoculate his government from headlines such as “back-flip” and “back-down” when the inevitable changes are made to Abbott-era policies, Turnbull has attempted early to depict such changes as the hallmark of an agile government and that it would be “rubbish” to label them as an admission of error.

He has also tried to minimise gazumps and gotchas by refusing to play the media’s favourite game, which is to force politicians to rule things in or out, thereby leaving them exposed to broken promises at a later date.

Turnbull’s “new” approach actually hearkens to an older era, when politicians’ engagement with the media was more open and less about risk minimisation. That’s not to necessarily say there was a time when politicians were more honest with the media. But in this era of slick sound bites and focus-group tested slogans, it’s fair to say there’s never been a time when pollies have been less open with the truth.

This raises an interesting challenge for Turnbull and his Government. It may well be commendable to want to make Australia’s discussion of politics more adult, but will traditional and new media willingly go along with the change?

Both entities have established business models that, at least since the fall of Rudd, depend on pack-driven outrage, usually based on a broken commitment, an indulgence, or an imbalance in social equity. Backflips, broken promises and rorts sell more papers and generate more clicks than words of conciliation, acts of cooperation, or productive policy development.

“Man bites dog” will always beat “man pats dog” in the traditional news stakes, and increasingly drama-driven social media only serves to amplify the sensationalism.

Australians on social media may claim to want traditional media outlets to provide in-depth policy analysis instead of focusing on personalities and political machinations, but many seem to prefer politics to be conducted and reported as a gladiatorial sport than the respectful and democratic contest of ideas that PM Turnbull appears to aspire to.

Social media-driven sensationalism is now more important than substance when it comes to attracting eyes to screens. This is clear from the decision made by the establishment current affairs program Q&A to cast an individual such as Zaky Mallah in its line-up of questioners.

Our new PM may hanker for the days of gentlemanly banter across the despatch boxes at Question Time, or considered discourse in the Press Gallery afterwards, but sensationalism will remain the mainstay of tabloids and social media.

And while politically engaged social media participants in Australian are admittedly a small cohort, they nevertheless are a vocal and potentially influential subset of voters with the potential to shape politics – or at least how the traditional media perceives political events, given the media now monitors and plunders Twitter for news.

It is certainly commendable that Turnbull is encouraging us to revert to a kinder, gentler way of debating politics, but he may also need to find a way to feed voters’ appetite for tabloid-confected conflict and drama.

As Tony Abbott learned before him, Turnbull cannot afford to leave one part of the media untended. If he vacates the field, the PM’s opponents will swiftly and gladly fill the void.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Author: Drag0nista

Political columnist at The New Daily | Editor of Despatches & AusVotes 2019 | Author of On Merit, a book on the Liberals' *women problem*. Former Liberal staffer and industry lobbyist. Studying the entrails of federal politics since 1989. View all posts by Drag0nista

Author Drag0nistaPosted on October 5, 2015July 5, 2016Categories Media, Politics, Social mediaTags gotcha journalism, Malcolm Turnbull, political engagement, social media, traditional media

Post navigation

Previous Previous post: Turnbull follows the Howard blueprint
Next Next post: Sexism isn’t any less abhorrent when it’s directed at right-wing women

Recently popular

  • Contact
  • Credlin's feminist posturing rings hollow

Click the cover below to order my new book!

Enter your email address & click the button below to get email updates from Drag0nista's Blog.

Join 15,869 other followers

Recently popular

  • Contact
  • Credlin's feminist posturing rings hollow

Recent posts

  • On the telly
  • Fact check: Did Labor win the popular vote?
  • It can be tricky knowing left from right in the ALP
  • Election 2019: How Barnaby Joyce could be the final nail in Scott Morrison’s coffin
  • Election 2019: Why the press should never, ever let politicians bury them with blather

Twitter Updates

  • RT @kcarruthers: Five 🦉🦉🦉🦉🦉 twitter.com/britishlibrary… 1 day ago
Follow @drag0nista

Just browsing?

  • Politics
  • Politicians
  • Political parties
  • Parliament
  • Women
  • Media
  • Social media
  • Other musings
  • Energy
  • My book: On Merit

Search posts by date

October 2015
M T W T F S S
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031  
« Sep   Nov »

Or choose a tag

  • Abbott Government
  • ALP
  • asylum seekers
  • Ausvotes 2016
  • Bill Shorten
  • Bronwyn Bishop
  • Budget
  • by election
  • Canning
  • carbon price
  • carbon tax
  • climate action
  • climate change
  • Clive Palmer
  • Coalition
  • conservatives
  • crossbench
  • double dissolution
  • election
  • ETS
  • featured
  • federal election
  • Greens
  • GST
  • Guardian Australia
  • jobs
  • Joe Hockey
  • John Howard
  • journalists
  • Julia Gillard
  • Julie Bishop
  • Kevin Rudd
  • Kings Tribune
  • Labor
  • Laurie Oakes
  • leadership
  • Liberal
  • Liberal Party
  • lies
  • mainstream media
  • Malcolm Turnbull
  • marriage equality
  • Mathias Cormann
  • media
  • moderates
  • negative politics
  • Newspoll
  • objectivity
  • opinion polls
  • Paul Keating
  • Peta Credlin
  • Peter Dutton
  • Peter Slipper
  • Politicians
  • politics
  • prime minister
  • progressive
  • PUP
  • same sex marriage
  • Scott Morrison
  • Senate
  • sexism
  • slide
  • social media
  • Speaker
  • terrorism
  • The Hoopla
  • The New Daily
  • Tony Abbott
  • trust
  • TURC
  • twitter
  • unions
  • voter expectation
  • voters

If all else fails…

Copyright

Copyright © 2010-18 Drag0nista. All Rights Reserved. Approval can be obtained to reproduce posts with attribution by using the form on the Contact page.

  • My book: On Merit
  • Who is Drag0nista?
  • Published pieces
  • Drag0nista in the media
  • Contact
  • Need a freelance writer?
    • Writing samples
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Tumblr
  • Google +
Drag0nista's Blog Website Built with WordPress.com.
loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
%d bloggers like this: